Think of a country. Any country. Excluding like Canada, Finland, Switzerland, or any other crap like that. Alright, now do some research on the slums in that country, and make up a story about someone struggling to escape.
Congratulations, you just came up with the screenplay for a future critically-acclaimed film.
What Slumdog Millionaire and City of God did for India and Brazil, respectfully, Sin Nombre does for Mexico; that is, makes it so that anyone who sees the movie never wants to visit that country ever, ever again. Admittedly, most of us knew the conditions of these nations before seeing the films. But seeing the situation portrayed so vividly on the screen makes it something tangible for the viewer, making it more "real" than it would be from simply reading an article on it.
Our main character is Willy, known by his gang name, "El Casper". The first minutes of the film consist of him watching over a new initiate to his gang, the Mara Salvatrucha. The young recruit, about 12 or so, is nicknamed "Smiley," and the leader of their chapter of the gang is named "Lil' Mago", continuing the long-standing tradition of Latin American gang members having the least intimidating name possible (including the City of God characters "Lil' Ze", "Benny", and, my favorite, "Carrot". Somehow, "Oh shit guys, Carrot just shot a cop!" doesn't sound right.)
Willy's girlfriend shows up one of their meetings, and before he can get her out of there, Lil' Mago insists upon showing her out. He attempts to rape her, killing her in the process, after which he nonchalantly tells Willy "You'll find another." By the way, none of this is spoilers. This all happens in the exposition, which should lend an idea of how depressing this film is.
For whatever reason, Lil' Mago decides to take Smiley and Willy, the guy whose girlfriend he just killed, off to do a job that very night. Oh, and he gives Willy a machete and a gun. Alright, I'm not really an expert in running a crime syndicate, but it seems to me that you don't supply a fellow gangmember whose life you just ruined with the means, location, and opportunity to kill you on the same day. Maybe one of those, and maybe you wait a day or two, but Lil' Mago just seems reckless.
Anyways, they wind up robbing people sitting on the roof of a train heading towards Texas. They stumble upon a girl named Sayra, a young Honduran illegally going with her father and uncle to New Jersey by way of Texas. Well, Lil' Mago, having a rape quota apparently not filled by Willy's girl, starts raping this poor migrant (with her father not two feet away.) Inevitably, Willy kills Lil' Mago with a machete to the neck, stays on the train, and sends Smiley back to the gang. The other migrants on the train see Willy as a threat, because of the notoriety of the MS, and plot to kill him. Luckily, Sayra sees him not as a threat, but as her savior, and in turn warns him of the plot. Smiley, back with the gang, now begins trying to track down Willy for vengeance, with help from basically every gang member in the country of Mexico. From then on, the movie is essentially a race between Willy and Sayra trying to reach the border, and the MS trying to find Willy.
Although Sin Nombre shares the idea of a gang in a third-world country, it's far from the same story as Slumdog or City of God shoved in a new locale: unlike the former, the film is definitely no inspiring love story; it's his love for his late girlfriend that really even causes the conflict to start. And, unlike the latter, the movie does not detail a struggle between two powerful gangs, but is about one man running from the dominant gang in Mexico, and even parts of America. And, different from both, the film lacks any real comic relief or underlying optimism. I know many people who wouldn't like that, but the gritty realness of this film would be lost if they threw in a joke or two.
Some viewers (my dad) may find the ending predictable. And, I'll admit, it seems to be the only logical place that the film could go. But people who let that distract from the quality of the film shouldn't be allowed to watch good cinema, if they spend their time trying to guess what's going to happen (like my dad.) The acting and directing are superb, and though the script suffers a little, this film wound up being one of the few films from 2009 that I wished were longer. My favorite drama of the year, I hope to see this garner attention from Academy voters. It went completely ignored at the Golden Globes, largely due to its unfortunate limited release date in March, and I fear that it will suffer the same fate at the Oscars. However, Sin Nombre connected with me the most, and kept me engaged the most of any film from 2009.
Overall Score: 10/10